Evidence of the Affair by Taylor Jenkins Reid – #MiniBookReview

Goodreads: Evidence of the Affair
Genre: Contemporary Fiction, Romance, Short Story

Dear stranger…
A desperate young woman in Southern California sits down to write a letter to a man she’s never met—a choice that will forever change both their lives.

My heart goes out to you, David. Even though I do not know you…

The correspondence between Carrie Allsop and David Mayer reveals, piece by piece, the painful details of a devastating affair between their spouses. With each commiserating scratch of the pen, they confess their fears and bare their souls. They share the bewilderment over how things went so wrong and come to wonder where to go from here. Told entirely through the letters of two comforting strangers and those of two illicit lovers, Evidence of the Affair explores the complex nature of the heart. And ultimately, for one woman, how liberating it can be when it’s broken.

I’ve had this sitting on my Kindle for a while now and only realized yesterday that it’s a short story. So, feeling in a bit of a restless reading mood, I decided to start it on a whim and I’m so glad that I did!

This story is written in the form of letters between Carrie Allsop and David Mayer. Carrie reaches out to David after finding letters from his wife to her husband, and what follows is a sad and sweet correspondence between the two, as they turn to and support each other in the after of this tumultuous discovery. Through their exchanges, Reid manages to not only display but also evoke a wide range of emotions. These letters are filled with heartbreak and defeat, insecurity and longing, but also with hope, passion and love. Carrie and David were such compassionate characters and my heart really went out to them. They were just regular people with relatable lives who found themselves in one of the worst situations, and it was hard not to feel invested in them despite only spending a short time together.

“It is funny the crazy things our brains make up to save us from the truth.”

As someone who has been in a relationship with a cheating partner and finding out through text messages, some of the emotions displayed on the page felt like a shot right to my gut and tore my heart open again. Reading the hurtful words was a little bit like dejavu and helped me really identify with the raw and real heartbreak and confusion that these two characters face.

“It was just easier to consider the possibility that he’d changed his entire personality overnight than it was to believe that he would cheat. But he’s the same Ken I’ve always known and loved […]. It’s just that he’s capable of things I never knew.”

Carrie’s revelation in her last letter, while surprising, wasn’t all that shocking and it added a nice victorious twist to the story. I’m glad that it ended that way because if it had continued then I felt it would’ve just become too messy. As it was, the ending felt incredibly freeing and like a weight had been lifted!

With Evidence of the Affair, I’m once again reminded why Reid has a firm spot on my list of auto buy authors. I continue to be amazed with her simple yet powerful and evocative writing style. It’s another win for me!

Have you read Evidence of the Affair? Loved it? Hated it? Meh about it? Leave a comment below and let’s chat books (and TJR!) 🙂

13 thoughts on “Evidence of the Affair by Taylor Jenkins Reid – #MiniBookReview

  1. Great review! I read TJR’s Daisy Jones and feel like the only person out there who didn’t really like it but I do want to give her a second chance at some stage and maybe a short story might be a good option 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve only read one TJR book but it was impressive. I’ll definitely read more of her stuff. And glad to hear this was so powerful a read- I didn’t realize it was a short story either! I’ve seen that cover around a few times. I’m glad to hear too that the ending is kinda uplifting, given the story and the heartache these characters must go through.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks Greg! Which book did you read?

      It is uplifting and a bit bittersweet but it felt like a ‘victory’ after the rest of the story. Recommended if you’re looking for a quick read. I’m looking forward to reading more too 😃


        • Ooh, I loved Maybe in Another Life! That was my first TJR and I just love the whole idea of that book. That speech at the end had me turning into mush! Haha I’m such a sappy hopeless romantic 🙈


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s